Friday, February 19, 2010

Announcing Ethica's Ethiopia Transparency Survey

In the interest of advancing transparency in adoptions in Ethiopia, Ethica has invited all U.S. agencies with Ethiopia international adoption programs to provide information about their Ethiopia program by taking part in a brief survey. Agency responses will be posted and participating Adoption Service Providers will be acknowledged on Ethica's website. All agencies known by Ethica to have licensed Ethiopia programs have been notified about the survey.

Ethica's Ethiopia Transparency Survey may be found at:

http://www.ethicanet.org/ethiopiasurvey

If you have any questions about the survey, please contact Ethica at andrea@ethicanet.org

PEAR is encouraging all prospective and adoptive parents to request that their agencies participate in this survey. Like Ethica, we have had a very difficult time reconciling the vast difference in information from agency to agency concerning the adoption process and post adoption experiences of PAPs and APs. As a result, we have a difficult time offering guidance and support to those who contact us for assistance. We believe that participation in Ethica's survey will be a key piece in sorting out the truth and working together to ensure that Ethiopian adoption programs are transparent and ethical.


Ethics, Transparency, Support
~ What All Adoptions Deserve.
http://www.pear-now.org/

Thursday, February 18, 2010

UPDATE: Haiti Teleconference

Today PEAR took part in the first hour of a teleconference with USCIS International Operations Division, DHS, DOS and other government agencies to discuss the ongoing process of bringing children into the US on Humanitarian Parole visas.

The primary discussion was effect that resumption of commercial flights will have on getting HP children to the US. Once commercial flights resume on Friday, February 19, the military will have to reduce its flights so as not to compete with the commercial flights. DHS will continue to work with adopting families to secure remaining military flights during the transition period (approximately two weeks) or to locate other private aircraft flights able to escort the children into the US.

Once it becomes necessary to book commercial flights for the children, adopting parents will have to reserve seats for their children and possibly for an adult escort and cover those costs. American Airlines is the only commercial carrier resuming flights. American requires an escort ratio of 2:1 for infants and all children under 15 must be escorted. DHS will work closely with adopting parents to secure the proper number of seats and coordinate timing. Adopting families are discouraged from attempting to fly to Haiti to retrieve the children.

The following is the outline of the process DHS foresees:

1. HP is approved at the Embassy.
2. The child is immediately placed on the prime minister list for travel approval.
3. The Prime Minister will sign the travel approval (this process has slowed down due to other obligations of the Prime Minister but is still occurring).
4. The Embassy will immediately notify parents when the approval is signed and will inform parents of the options available for bringing home their child.
5. If there is no military or private flight available, parents will need to book a flight with American Airlines. The only point of entry the children will be permitted to enter the US is Miami, so all flights must be booked from PaP to Miami. Once a flight is booked, parents will notify the Embassy and the Embassy will secure the proper documents and escort the child to the airport. The Embassy will work with parents on contacting the orphanage or guardian of the child with travel plans and coordinating the process.

The process is malleable at this point as DHS works though the complications this transition may present.

DHS also provided the following information on the process to date:

So far, travel has been authorized for over 800 children. They expect a considerable number of cases to receive travel authorization tomorrow (Friday February 19). DHS is aware of a possible flight via a charitable organization on Friday if the travel authorizations are signed.

DHS anticipated approximately 900 applications and has received 1300. About 5% of the cases reviewed have been found ineligible. DHS still continues to encourage prospective adoptive parents who began the Haitian adoption process prior to the earthquake to review the criteria for eligibility and contact DHS if they feel they have a chance at meeting those criteria.

DHS has shifted from processing groups of children by orphanage to processing individual children as they are ready which has quickened the pace of approvals. Each case is reviewed twice and is given individual care and attention.

In addition to the above information, DHS announced that it will provide a teleconfernce early next week for disseminating information on obtaining citizenship and finalizing adoptions for children who entered the US under Humanitarian Parole. A date and time have not yet been fixed. PEAR will publish this information as soon as we receive it.


Ethics, Transparency, Support
~ What All Adoptions Deserve.
http://www.pear-now.org/

STUDY: Assessment of Child Protection Needs in Post-Earthquake Haiti

The New England Journal of Medicine published the following on February 17, 2010
http://content.nejm.org/cgi/content/full/NEJMp1001820

Protecting the Children of Haiti
Satchit Balsari, M.D., M.P.H., Jay Lemery, M.D., Timothy P. Williams,
M.S.W., M.Sc., and Brett D. Nelson, M.D., M.P.H., D.T.M.&H

Haiti has long had difficulty in protecting its children from harm. The earthquake that struck the country on January 12 destroyed much of the capital, Port-au-Prince, as it killed many government officials and United Nations (UN) workers and left as many as 230,000 people dead and many thousands injured. In the wake of this sweeping disaster, the plight of Haiti's children has acquired new and terrible dimensions.

On January 24, we went to Haiti as members of a team sent by the François-Xavier Bagnoud Center for Health and Human Rights at Harvard University to conduct a multisite rapid assessment of child-protection needs in the post-earthquake environment, where it was already evident that children were at grave risk of abandonment, abuse, and trafficking. The focus was on the current systems and practices for identifying and caring for unaccompanied children and for tracing those who had been separated from their families and reuniting them with parents or guardians. Longer-term interventions to promote the welfare, rights, and safety of this population were also examined.

In 9 days, we interviewed more than 25 stakeholders in Haiti, including government officials, local staff members, humanitarian aid workers, and representatives of domestic and international nongovernmental organizations and UN agencies. We visited field hospitals, clinics, shelters, and orphanages, along with observing risk-assessment practices and participating in meetings of UN "clusters" (groups focused on individual service sectors).

Children constitute almost half of Haiti's population of 9 million. Before the earthquake, an estimated 350,000 children lived in "orphanages," yet only 50,000 of them had no living parents. Desperately poor families have often felt compelled to place children in residential care facilities, only to return later and find that they have been given away for adoption. Throughout the world, many families have historically relinquished their children when they reached a tipping point due to unmanageable birth rates; parental death, disability, or unemployment; physical insecurity; displacement; or natural disasters. In pre-earthquake Haiti, many families had already reached such a crisis.

Local officials estimate that there are about 350 registered orphanages in the country and about twice as many unregistered and unregulated ones. Even most registered institutions do not meet international UN guidelines. A related long-standing threat to child protection has been the common practice of sending children away as /restavèks/ (Creole for "stay with") to live with others in exchange for work. An estimated 150,000 to 500,000 /restavèks/ work essentially as unpaid domestic laborers, with little or no access to education or recreation and subject to physical, mental, and sexual abuse.The /restavèk/ situation and the practice of institutionalizing children reflect the extreme destitution of Haitian families. Thus, the earthquake occurred against a background of economic extremity driving family separation,aggressive trafficking networks, inadequate law enforcement, and a growing global demand for adoptive children.

Parents died and families were splintered as a result of the earthquake. In the rush to provide emergency care, injured adults and children were often scattered, taken to the nearest available health care facilities, and sometimes transferred, without records, to other centers. This situation prevailed for a month, during which time little, if any, demographic or registration information was collected at sites of care or settlement. Critical early opportunities to record, identify, and trace children and families were lost. The lack of data has impaired all aspects of child-protection efforts.

Irregular settlement adds further risk. By January 31, there were 1.1 million Haitians in need of shelter in Port-au-Prince and the surrounding communes, living in 591 documented improvised settlements — some of which, like the Petionville Club, hosted as many as 100,000 refugees. Children and young people in these dense settlements are easy targets for organized crime, violence, and sexual exploitation.

This disaster has imposed a massive socioeconomic burden on a country that was already struggling with poor governance and an impoverished population. Stripped of all assets by the earthquake, a growing number of families are parting with their children. Given Haiti's unregulated borders, weak law-enforcement practices, and insufficient numbers of international monitors, traffickers face few deterrents. There is growing consternation among child-protection workers about the lack of financial and human resources for protecting Haiti's vulnerable child population, which is estimated by some at 1 million.

The /restavèk/ phenomenon and unregulated "orphanages" pose challenges to the placement of unaccompanied children. Although international standard practice is for orphans to be promptly returned to their relatives or communities, the /restavèk/ option and severe poverty make community-based solutions problematic. Many aid workers feel compelled to consider institutional placement as a safer interim solution. But safe institutions are hard to come by. We encountered several hospitals where unaccompanied children whose treatment was complete were not being released for lack of a safe discharge plan (though in the first few weeks after the earthquake, many unaccompanied children had been discharged to the street). Representatives of orphanages visit camps and hospitals daily, and there is no effective mechanism for distinguishing safe residential care facilities from fronts for trafficking.

Adoption is sometimes seen as a viable alternative in the face of destitution. Experience from past disasters and conflicts, however, suggests that adoptions in the immediate wake of such crises carry a high risk of permanent removal of children who are not actually orphans — a practice that inevitably inflames latent nationalist sentiment in the affected region. The fields of child human rights and child psychology place great emphasis on maintaining the integrity of the family unit, where children have the best chance of being raised in a loving, intimate environment. There is great need now to provide care for thousands of children, including those with medical and other postoperative needs, and in some instances temporary protection status or adoption across borders might be acceptable. But a much better system for tracing children and protecting borders must first be implemented, to reduce the risk that children will be torn from their own families who, given the means, would nurture and care for them.

Improved family-tracing procedures, border control, effective scrutiny of international adoptions in line with the Hague Convention on Protection of Children and Cooperation in Respect of Intercountry Adoption, and more stringent oversight of orphanages are urgently needed to forestall further abuse. We believe that all aid workers, including voluntary health care professionals, should receive training in child-protection norms and be sensitized to the prevalence of child abandonment, abduction, and trafficking. Child-protection basics, including identification procedures and record keeping, reestablishment of educational opportunities, creation of child-friendly spaces (set up specifically for children in crises to address their physical and psychosocial needs in a stable, trustworthy environment), and health interventions, must be ramped up rapidly. Additional steps must be taken to strengthen local governmental and policing institutions charged with child protection, specifically the Ministry for Social Welfare and Research and the Brigade for the Protection of Minors.

A sustained strategy must be developed to mitigate the distress and insecurity of affected children. The challenges of tracing and family reunification must be addressed through streamlined data-acquisition systems, heightened public awareness, and community-driven monitoring initiatives. Attention to child welfare and disability-related needs is essential, even as economic strategies are found to enable families and communities to achieve a reasonable standard of living. A common refrain heard among aid workers is that to ensure safe childhoods,families must be given a fair chance to be economically viable — which requires investments^ in health, education, vocational skills, sustainable livelihoods, microfinancing, and improved agricultural practices.

A senior aid worker spoke for many seasoned responders when he said,"We must be firmly committed to this notion of building back Haiti better. We must not accept the /restavèk/ phenomenon as the inevitable. We must build a society free of /restavèks./ Children belong in their communities." This goal will be difficult to achieve. Yet, as the UN's special rapporteur recently remarked, "The human security of every child is of utmost importance to the sustainable development of a society based on human rights and [is] a precondition for sustainable peace."

An imaginative, bold solution is required. Recovery from an earthquake is always complex and slow, but Haiti's children should not be made to wait and suffer. One million vulnerable children are a very large share of Haiti's future and of ours.









Ethics, Transparency, Support
~ What All Adoptions Deserve.
http://www.pear-now.org/

UPDATE: DOS Notice - Nepal

Nepal Adoption Notice



U.S. DEPARTMENT OF STATE
Bureau of Consular Affairs
Office of Children’s Issues



February 17, 2010

The Hague Conference on Private International Law has recently released a report on its Intercountry Adoption Technical Assistance Program, based on a visit by the Hague delegate to Nepal in November 2010 (http://www.hcch.net/upload/wop/nepal_rpt09.pdf). This report is based on an independent analysis of Nepal’s inter-country adoption system under its new Terms and Conditions 2008. The report details a number of weaknesses in Nepal’s current system, including the falsification of documents, improper financial gain and lack of a child protection system.

The U.S. Department of State shares many of the concerns outlined in the Hague report. In one of the first cases processed by the Government of Nepal after the revision of the Terms and Conditions, the U.S. Embassy in Kathmandu found that the child in question was not a true orphan and that the child’s biological parents were actively searching for the child.

We caution prospective adoptive parents who have yet to choose a country that the intercountry adoption system in Nepal is not yet reliable. For prospective adoptive parents who currently have active files at the Ministry of Women, Children and Social Welfare, we remind you that consular officers are required by law to conduct an orphan investigation (I-604) to verify the child's orphan status prior to the issuance of an IR-3 or IR-4 immigrant visa. Depending on the circumstances of a case, this investigation may take up to several months to complete and some matched children may not be found to be adoptable under U.S. immigration law. Prospective adoptive parents should therefore carefully consider whether to file their Form I-600 Petition to Classify an Orphan as an Immediate Relative with the Department of Homeland Security, United States Citizenship and Immigration Services in the U.S. or at the U.S. Embassy in Kathmandu, as the Embassy’s I-604 investigation cannot begin until the I-600 has been filed and the documents have been reviewed by a consular officer.

The U.S. Embassy in Kathmandu continues to meet with officials within the Government of Nepal and work with the Office of Children’s issues to provide updated information to the public as it becomes available.


http://adoption.state.gov/news/nepal.html

Cross posted on PEAR's Nepal Blog


Ethics, Transparency, Support
~ What All Adoptions Deserve.
http://www.pear-now.org/

UPDATE: DOS Notice - Uganda

Uganda

Adoption Notice

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF STATE
Bureau of Consular Affairs
Office of Children’s Issues


Status of Adoptions from Uganda

February 17, 2010

Contrary to rumors that have been circulating, the U.S. Embassy in Kampala has NOT ceased processing adoption cases, but legal complications in Uganda have arisen that are likely to cause significant delays in the processing of most adoption cases.

On February 2, 2010 The Honorable Lady Justice Margaret C. Oguli Oumo, Family Court Judge, informed the U.S. Embassy in Kampala that legal guardianship orders issued by the High Court of Uganda are issued with the understanding that United States citizens will not adopt Ugandan children in the United States and that the Ugandan children will not change their citizenship.

A key requirement of IR-4 immigrant visa eligibility is that the prospective adoptive parent(s) (PAPs) obtain legal custody of the child for the purposes of emigration and adoption abroad. Guardianship orders that merely permit the guardians to travel with the child outside of Uganda and do not permit the guardians to fix the abode of the child may not meet the requirements of U.S. immigration law for the purpose of IR-4 visa issuance.

If there is a doubt as to the meaning of a custody order, consular officers must seek clarification from appropriate government authorities. If the consular officer ultimately determines the order to be sufficient to meet the requirements for IR-4 visa issuance, the case can be processed to conclusion. If the consular officer determines the order to be insufficient, the embassy is required to submit the I-600 petition to USCIS for review. (If the I-600 was locally filed it would go to the USCIS office with jurisdiction as not clearly approvable; if it was approved in the United States it would be returned through the National Visa Center to the USCIS office in the United States that originally approved the petition.)

http://adoption.state.gov/news/uganda.html



Ethics, Transparency, Support
~ What All Adoptions Deserve.
http://www.pear-now.org/